THE PRACTICE CHECK-UP

WHERE DID THAT
PATIENT GO?

Nine places new patients slip away — and how to find them.

A self-assessment for private practice owners.

TAKE THE CHECK-UP

20 YEARS MARKETING DENTAL PRACTICES · 1M+ CALLS LISTENED TO · 100% REFERRAL-GROWN

YOU’RE LOSING PATIENTS
YOU ALREADY PAID FOR.

Every month you spend money to make the phone ring. And every month, some of the people who call walk right back out — quietly, without telling you.

A woman calls about a crown. She asks the price, hears the number, says thanks, and hangs up. Your team writes her off as a bad lead. But nobody listened to that call. Nobody called her back. Was she a bad lead — or did the conversation just never get a chance?

That’s the leak. It’s not one big hole. It’s a slow drip at every step: the call that wasn’t answered well, the form nobody checked, the “let me think about it” nobody followed up on. Each drip looks like nothing. Together, they’re the reason your schedule has openings your marketing report can’t explain.

Here’s the uncomfortable part: if you’re not measuring each step, you’re guessing. And most practices are guessing.

This check-up walks you through the nine places patients slip away. Score each one honestly. Then start with your lowest — that’s where your patients are going.

THE MATH OF A LEAK

Imagine 100 people reach out. 70 get a good answer on the phone. 50 book. 40 show up. 28 start treatment.
You didn’t have a lead problem. You had 72 leaks.

HOW TO USE THIS CHECK-UP

Give each of the nine areas a score from 1 to 10. One means look into it right away. Ten means you’ve checked it recently and have good reason to feel confident.

Score what actually happens in your office — not what you hope happens. If you don’t know, that’s something to check too. Walk through it as someone who’s never met you, doesn’t know dental terminology, and may already be nervous about calling.

Then go back to the area you scored lowest. That’s where you start.

01  YOUR MESSAGE

If your website sounds like every other dentist in town — friendly team, personalized care, latest technology — patients can’t tell you apart. So they compare the only things left: price and convenience. You lose good patients before you ever meet them, and you never hear about it.

MEASURE THIS: Ask your last 10 new patients why they chose you. Write the answers down word for word. If “you were closest” keeps winning, your message isn’t doing the work.

02  GETTING FOUND

You can rank number one for your own name and still be invisible. The patient with a cracked molar isn’t searching your name — they’re searching for the treatment. If you’re not there for the procedures you want to do more of, those patients book somewhere else and you’ll never know they existed.

MEASURE THIS: Pick the three treatments you want more of. Search each one like a patient — on your phone, from your parking lot. Write down where you show up.

03  YOUR WEBSITE

Your website has one job: turn interest into a booked appointment. Most of the time it’s doing the opposite — slow pages, a phone number you can’t tap, a form that errors out on mobile. Every bit of friction is a patient who meant to call you and didn’t.

MEASURE THIS: Book with your own office from your phone, start to finish. Time it. Count the taps. Every tap you can remove is a leak you just fixed.

04  YOUR PHONES

This is where the “bad lead” myth lives. Somebody asks, “How much is a crown?” Your team quotes a price. They hang up. Bad lead, right? Not always. Price is just the only question a nervous stranger knows how to ask. Answer it, explain what changes the fee, and give them a next step — or watch a good patient become somebody else’s.

MEASURE THIS: Listen to 10 new-patient calls this week. Count how many booked. That percentage is your phone conversion rate — the most expensive number in your practice, and most owners have never heard it.

05  SCHEDULING

They found you. They liked you. They called. And then there was no appointment that worked — so they called the next office. You did everything right and still lost them in the last ten feet.

MEASURE THIS: Pull 10 inquiries that didn’t book. How many mentioned timing? If your schedule has no room for new patients, that’s not a marketing problem.

06  FOLLOW-UP

The person who didn’t book isn’t gone — they’re undecided. But once the phone rings again, yesterday’s inquiry disappears into a pile nobody owns. No name on it. No next step. No call back. A week later they’re sitting in someone else’s chair.

MEASURE THIS: Right now, how many open inquiries are sitting with no follow-up scheduled? If you can’t answer in 30 seconds, that’s the leak.

07  TREATMENT CONVERSATIONS

“Let me think about it” is not an answer — it’s a question hiding. Are they worried about the money? The time off? Whether it’ll hurt? If nobody asks, you present the same plan the same way and hope. Hope is not a case acceptance strategy.

MEASURE THIS: Track what happens after “let me think about it.” How many get a follow-up call? How many start? That gap is treatment walking out your back door.

08  REVIEWS AND REFERRALS

Your happiest patients already did the hard part — they trust you. But a stranger comparing three practices can’t see that if your reviews are old, vague, or buried. They pick the office with recent reviews that sound like real people. That’s not vanity. That’s your reputation working while you sleep — or not.

MEASURE THIS: How many new reviews did you get last month? How many referrals? If you’re not counting, you’re not growing them.

09  YOUR NUMBERS

This is the one that makes the other eight make sense. Inquiries. Booked. Showed. Started. Four numbers. If you know all four, you know exactly where patients are slipping away — and you stop blaming the leads for a leak that’s happening inside your office.

MEASURE THIS: Write down last month’s four numbers. Can’t find one? That’s your lowest score. Start there.

WHAT ARE YOU GOING
TO CHECK FIRST?

Go back to your scores. The section that made you uncomfortable — that’s the one. Before you spend another dollar making the phone ring, go look at what happens when it does. Listen to the calls. Try the form. Count the leaks.

If you want a second set of eyes, bring your check-up. We’ll start with your lowest score.

BOOK A 15-MINUTE CALL
Killer Shark Marketing
EST. 2006  ·  DDS & MD